When the Old Maps Become Dangerous: Experience, Certainty and a World in Transition | Leadership & Consciousness
The Pivot Dialogues with Dave SchoofNovember 04, 2026x
20
00:23:3932.49 MB

When the Old Maps Become Dangerous: Experience, Certainty and a World in Transition | Leadership & Consciousness

A solo leadership episode on messy times and why we need to be careful relying on old maps.

Wars, AI, financial markets, and climate disruption are moving at once and affecting one another. We can see it happening, but we don't yet understand it. In this episode, I share what I'm seeing from where I stand, including what 19 years in counterintelligence and my own coaching taught me about the cost of pattern recognition. Seeing fresh is what lets us choose how to act.

In this episode:

  • Why this moment deserves more attention than "the world is always changing"
  • What counterintelligence taught me about capable people misreading situations
  • How I stopped diagnosing my clients, and what curiosity brought back
  • Why leaders double down when conditions change, and how identity keeps us defending what isn't working
  • Holding what we know differently, including what we notice when we stop rehearsing our explanations

 

🔗 CONNECT WITH DAVE

Website: https://daveschoof.com

Substack: https://dschoof.substack.com

Pivot Lab: [Pivot Lab info page on daveschoof.com]

Pivot Commons:

https://www.daveschoof.com/pivotlab

[ https://www.skool.com/the-pivot-commons-4650/about?ref=99a271ec9e194ed5a83253bc91a78dc6 ]

LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/daveschoof/

[00:00:00] I do think that this is a serious moment and I wonder whether some of the ways we've learned to understand and navigate the world are becoming less reliable than we realize. That's what I want to explore today. Because I've been thinking about a key question that is becoming increasingly provocative. What if some of the very things that have made us successful are now preventing us from seeing what's actually happening?

[00:00:25] I've spent 19 years working in counterintelligence and one of the things I learned is that highly capable intelligent people can have access to enormous amounts of information and still misunderstand what's happening. Sometimes quite profoundly. Welcome to The Pivot Dialogues, where we explore the shifts that open new possibilities for how we see, act and navigate the world.

[00:00:50] Right now, so much is changing, faster than we can make sense of. It's easy to feel unmoored, caught between an unraveling past and a future that's still, well, taking shape. But there are those who can already see what's emerging, beyond the noise, beyond the confusion.

[00:01:11] In each episode, I sit down with visionaries, thinkers, practitioners, and pioneers who are not just imagining the future, but actually living it. They're sensing what's next and mapping the way forward. So if you're wondering how to navigate this shifting landscape, how to stay grounded, adapt, and even thrive, you're in the right place. This is not about quick fixes or the seven steps to be more effective.

[00:01:39] This is about asking the right questions of yourself, of each other, of life. Learning how to make sense of this changing terrain and how to move in it. You don't have to figure it out alone. I've got you covered. This is The Pivot Dialogues. Welcome. Hi. We're living through a remarkable period in history. And I don't mean that in the usual sense of saying the world's changing because the world's always been changing.

[00:02:09] But there's something about this particular moment that deserves our attention. It is different. Things are happening at different levels and at speeds that we haven't encountered before. Look at what's happening. Wars and geopolitical tensions are disrupting energy markets and supply chains. Key elections happening around the world are consuming everyone's attention.

[00:02:34] Artificial intelligence is developing at a pace that's challenging our assumptions about work, business, and even what it means to be human. Financial markets are absorbing enormous investments in technologies whose long-term consequences we actually don't yet fully understand. And climate disruptions are increasingly affecting agriculture, infrastructure, and communities around the world.

[00:03:01] And these, again, they're not occurring independently of one another. They're interacting, sometimes in ways that are difficult to anticipate. The International Energy Agency has been documenting how disruptions in Gulf energy supplies extend far beyond oil markets.

[00:03:23] The IMF, the International Monetary Fund, has been warning about vulnerabilities associated with AI investments, government debt, and cyber threats. And the World Meteorological Organization continues to highlight how changing climate patterns are creating risks across food production, water supplies, and infrastructure. Now, I'm not bringing all this up to frighten anyone. I'm not a gloom and doom guy.

[00:03:50] And I don't believe we're witnessing the end of times. I've lived through enough history and I've seen enough of the world to have considerable confidence in human ingenuity and our ability to adapt. But I do think that this is a serious moment. And I wonder whether some of the ways we've learned to understand and navigate the world are becoming less reliable than we realize. That's what I want to explore today.

[00:04:20] Because I've been thinking about a key question that is becoming increasingly provocative. What if some of the very things that have made us successful are now preventing us from seeing what's actually happening? Our experience, our expertise, our ways we've learned to solve problems and make decisions. We've spent years developing those capabilities and they've served us well.

[00:04:47] But what happens when the conditions that made them so useful begin to change? And how would we know? I've spent 19 years working in counterintelligence. And one of the things I learned is that highly capable, intelligent people can have access to enormous amounts of information and still misunderstand what's happening. Sometimes quite profoundly.

[00:05:16] In intelligence work, pattern recognition is critical. It's essential. You learn to notice things that other people might overlook. You connect seemingly unrelated information and you make judgments when you don't have the complete picture. Especially in fast changing situations. And there's a danger that comes with becoming really good at that. I know this personally.

[00:05:42] Once you've recognized a pattern, you can become remarkably effective at finding evidence that supports it. And remarkably skilled at explaining away anything that doesn't fit. That's confirmation bias, of course. But knowing that term doesn't make us immune to it. I've seen it in intelligence work, in organizations, in my clients, and in myself.

[00:06:09] And I've come to appreciate that one of the casualties of familiarity is curiosity. When something looks familiar, we tend to stop looking quite so carefully. Have you noticed that? We believe that we understand what's happening because we've encountered something like that before. Pattern recognition. And often we're right. Don't get me wrong. That's what makes experience so valuable. But what happens when we're wrong?

[00:06:38] When the situation is changed in ways we haven't recognized. And our confidence in what we already know actually prevents us from noticing that shift. I think that's one of the more consequential challenges we're facing. Both individually and collectively. I recognize this tendency in my own work as a coach. For many years, I was quick to diagnose situations. Someone would walk in with a challenge and I'd listen. I'd ask questions.

[00:07:06] I would draw on my experience and training and I'd begin figuring out what was going on. I had plenty of tools. Assessment instruments, methodologies, frameworks, models. And they were all useful. They still are. But somewhere along the way, I began to notice that I was often listening through those frameworks. I was trying to understand the person by fitting what I was hearing into something I already knew.

[00:07:35] And I was pretty good at it. And that was part of the problem. Because the better I became at recognizing familiar patterns, the easier it was to overlook what didn't fit. And then I started slowly beginning to wonder what could I be missing. What would happen if I stopped trying to understand the person quite so quickly?

[00:08:00] If I became more interested in discovering who was actually sitting across from me rather than figuring out what was going on with them. That really changed something fundamental in my work and my effectiveness. Now, I didn't throw away my tools. They're still there. But I began to think of them as sitting in a bag right next to me, available whenever I needed them. I no longer had to look at the person through those tools.

[00:08:28] Instead, I could bring my experience into the conversation while remaining genuinely curious about what I didn't yet understand. And I discovered that there was something enormously enjoyable about that. That curiosity brought energy. And it wanted me to understand even more, open up more. The person in front of me became interesting in different ways.

[00:08:55] There was more to discover than whatever my initial impression or interpretation suggested. And sometimes, actually often, what emerged surprised both of us. And I found that I was learning as much personally as I was helping. Now, I'm not suggesting that everyone needs to approach their work the way I approach coaching. But what interests me is that shift that occurred.

[00:09:24] My knowledge hadn't disappeared. My experience hadn't become less valuable. But my relationship to what I knew had changed. And I think that's the implication that goes far beyond coaching. So think about something you're particularly good at. Maybe you've spent years, decades leading people, building organizations, making tough decisions, or solving really complex problems that others struggle with.

[00:09:54] You've developed judgment. You recognize patterns. You know what tends to work. And you've got plenty of evidence that your approach is effective. You've been successful. Why wouldn't you trust it? But here's the difficulty. Most of that evidence comes from the past. And when circumstances change, the very confidence that helped you succeed can make it harder to recognize that something important is different.

[00:10:24] I've seen leaders respond to changing circumstances by becoming even more committed to the approaches that made them successful. They double down. A team becomes less responsive, so the leader increases communication and tightens accountability. Results begin slipping, so the organization creates new and even more restrictive processes.

[00:10:49] A familiar strategy stops delivering, so everyone works harder to execute it. Now, sometimes those are exactly the right responses. But sometimes they're making things worse. And I'm seeing that happen more and more. Because the underlying situation has changed, and no one has stopped long enough to reconsider what they're actually dealing with right here, right now.

[00:11:16] And this is an uncomfortable possibility, especially for accomplished people. If you've spent much of your life being the person who knows what to do, what happens when you genuinely don't know? And if your sense of competence is deeply connected to your being able to figure things out, how easy is it to acknowledge that your understanding might be incomplete? You could be wrong.

[00:11:45] I think this is where it gets really interesting. Our familiar ways of operating aren't simply strategies we use. Over time, they become part of how we understand ourselves, our very identity. We become the problem solver, the strategist, the dependable one, the person that sees what others can't see. And when those identities are challenged, we become quite protective of the assumptions that support them.

[00:12:16] We may continue defending an approach long after we've begun to see evidence that it isn't working. Not necessarily because we're stubborn or unwilling to learn, but sometimes because acknowledging what has changed would require us to reconsider something very important about ourselves, how we know ourselves to be. So what does it mean to navigate differently?

[00:12:45] I don't think the answer is to throw away our experience or become suspicious of everything we've learned. You know, at this stage of my life, I value my experience enormously. I wouldn't want to give it up. But I've become more interested in how I hold what I know.

[00:13:04] One of the things I've been learning is to resist the temptation to reduce complicated situations to a choice between two opposing explanations, either this or this. Almost like a switch. And we do this all the time. Is artificial intelligence going to be good for humanity or bad for humanity? Are we facing a period of extraordinary opportunity or extraordinary danger?

[00:13:31] Should we preserve what's working or embrace something new? Those questions can pull us into choosing sides before we've adequately understood what's happening. We see this everywhere. Look at the polarization in our society today. And sometimes, more often than not, both sides contain something important. AI can create extraordinary possibilities while introducing serious risks.

[00:14:01] Stability can be valuable, and so can change. A leader may need to provide clear direction while remaining open, flexible to being influenced by the people they're leading. The challenge is recognizing what each side contributes and what happens when we pursue one at the expense of the other.

[00:14:22] I've found that when I can hold those tensions without immediately trying to resolve them, I often begin seeing possibilities that weren't apparent before. Something else that's become important to me is deliberately seeking out perspectives that are different from my own. Now, not because every opinion is equally well-founded. It isn't.

[00:14:47] But because I know there's almost always more to a situation than the story I've constructed about it. And sometimes, the other person sees something that I simply can't see from where I'm standing. That takes a certain willingness to be influenced. A permeability. And that's not always easy when you've spent a lifetime developing your own judgment.

[00:15:16] There's another dimension to this that I've come to appreciate more as I've gotten older. We can become so absorbed in thinking about a situation that we lose touch with what we're actually experiencing. We keep telling ourselves the story of what happened, why it happened, what someone meant, what should have been done, or what might happen next. And those stories keep pulling us back into the past.

[00:15:43] Sometimes I find it useful to stop for a moment and notice what's happening inside me. What's the weather system inside? What am I feeling? What are the emotions, sensations? What happens in my body when I consider a particular possibility? Is there a tightening? Is there a volatility? What am I sensing in the relationship with the person in front of me? That space between us.

[00:16:13] So, somatic and internal intelligence and relational intelligence. There's more information there that doesn't always become available just through analysis. Now, of course, our feelings, our bodily responses can also mislead us. They aren't infallible sources of truth. But neither is our thinking.

[00:16:34] And I suspect we're better equipped to navigate difficult circumstances when we have access to more of our intelligence rather than relying almost exclusively on the part of us that analyzes and explains and makes tight. For me, this has become less about finding the right framework and more about remaining available to what I haven't yet understood.

[00:17:01] I'd like to bring this back to a moment in your own life. Think about a situation where you're not getting the results that you expected or want. It might be something happening in work or a relationship that's become difficult. Maybe a consequential decision that you've been circling on or a direction that you've been pursuing for a while now, but it no longer feels quite right.

[00:17:31] You've probably given it a fair amount of thought already. And maybe you've tried several things. And because you're experienced, you probably have some pretty good ideas about what should work. But consider this possibility. What if the difficulty isn't that you haven't found the right solution? What if you're still trying to solve the situation as you understood it in the past, a year ago, and something important has changed in the meantime?

[00:18:03] And what have you been doing in response to this? Perhaps you've been gathering more information or working harder, trying to influence someone else's behavior or position, or looking for a better version of the same strategy that worked before. And what might you be overlooking because it doesn't fit the picture you've already formed? And there's another question that I think is worth asking.

[00:18:29] What would it mean for you if your understanding turned out to be wrong? Would you have to reconsider a commitment you've made, something you've invested years in, or perhaps even a familiar way of seeing yourself? I don't ask those questions lightly. I know how uncomfortable it can be to acknowledge that something you've relied on, that we've all relied on for years, may no longer be serving us.

[00:18:59] But I also know how much can become possible when we allow ourselves to see differently. And perhaps the place to begin isn't with another strategy. Perhaps it's with curiosity. What am I not seeing? What else might be true? What would I notice if I weren't already convinced I understood what was happening?

[00:19:24] And what happens if I stop rehearsing my explanation for a moment and I pay attention to what's right here? Again, you don't have to abandon your experience to ask those questions of yourself. You can keep everything you've learned. You may simply discover that some of it belongs in the bag beside you rather than directly in front of your eyes. Now I want to return to where we began, with the world we're living in.

[00:19:54] Because I think these questions matter far beyond our individual circumstances. We're entering territory that none of us fully understands. There are genuine threats, and I don't want to minimize them. Some of the choices being made today will have consequences for years, generations even. But I also believe there are many extraordinary possibilities emerging.

[00:20:19] And I don't think we can adequately understand this moment if we're committed to seeing only one side of it. I don't want to spend the years ahead consumed by anxiety about everything that might go wrong. I want to remain involved in life. I want to keep learning, contributing, enjoying the people I love, and discovering things I haven't yet experienced.

[00:20:44] And I want to meet whatever comes with as much intelligence, curiosity, and openness as I can bring to it. But that doesn't mean being naive about the dangers. It means recognizing that the way we respond matters. And we may not be able to control many of the developments unfolding around us. That's true. But we can become more attentive to how we're interpreting them, and how we're choosing to act.

[00:21:13] We can recognize when our familiar approaches are no longer producing the results we expect. We can become more willing to question what we think we know. And perhaps we can recover some of that curiosity that familiarity has gradually taken away from us. That's part of what I've been exploring through the pivot. What happens when the maps we've relied on stop describing the territory?

[00:21:43] How do we find our bearings without pretending we know exactly where we're going? And how do we continue growing, contributing, and finding enjoyment in life while navigating a world that's become increasingly difficult to predict? So I'll leave you with two questions. What if some of the very things that have made you successful are now preventing you from seeing what's happening?

[00:22:12] And where in your life have you become so certain of what you're looking at that you've stopped being curious about what actually might be there? I think those questions are worth spending some time with. Because sometimes, what we need isn't another answer. It's the willingness to discover something we haven't yet seen. Thanks for spending this time with me. I'll see you next time.

[00:22:40] This is Dave Schoof with The Pivot Dialogues Dialogues. Go well. Thank you for being here and for staying with what's unfolding. If this conversation opens something for you, I hope you'll carry it forward. And if someone comes to mind who might benefit, trust that and pass it along.

[00:23:04] If you'd like to continue the exploration, there's a link in the show notes to The Pivot Commons, a free space where these conversations can be explored more directly with others. A subscription, a review, a follow are always welcome. It's important because it helps others find their way here to this work. Until next time, keep listening, keep feeling, keep exploring, and keep finding your way.

[00:23:32] This is Dave Shove at The Pivot, where we meet at the edges. Go well.

© 2025 The Pivot with Dave Schoof All Rights Reserved.                                                                                     Privacy Policy